Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2021 / ib / Paper 3 / 19H / Solution

An $m\times n$ matrix game with payoff matrix $A$ is a two-player zero-sum game: player I chooses a row and receives $A_{ij}$, while player II chooses a column and loses the same amount. For mixed strategies $p$ and $q$, the expected payoff to player I isPlayer I's optimal mixed strategy maximizes the payoff guaranteed against every $q$, while player II's minimizes the largest payoff obtainable by any $p$. Thusby the minimax theorem. Equivalently, optimal strategies satisfy

Here $A^T=-A$, so this is an antisymmetric zero-sum game. For every probability vector $r$,It follows that the row player's guaranteed payoff cannot exceed zero and the column player's worst loss cannot be below zero. Minimax therefore givesIf $p$ is optimal for player I, thenTransposing and using $A^T=-A$ giveswhich is precisely the optimality condition for player II. Thus every optimal strategy for player I is also optimal for player II.

The condition $Ap\le 0$ explicitly readsThe probability vectorsatisfiesso it is optimal for both players.

To prove uniqueness, let $q$ be any optimal strategy. Since $p$ is optimal for player II and $q$ is optimal for player I,and hence $q_3=0$. Writing $q=(a,b,0,d{)}^T$, the first, second, and fourth inequalities in $Aq\le 0$ giveConsequentlyso equality holds throughout: $a=2d$ and $b=4d$. The normalization $a+b+d=1$ yields $d=1/7$. Therefore the displayed $p$ is the unique optimal strategy.

Solved by gpt-5.6-sol high.